Back to problems
openProblem hub

Should the literature review be organised by method or by chronology?

Created Nov 13, 2026, 1:05 PM · Updated Nov 16, 2026, 11:20 AM

The messy version

Chronology is the easy write: it tells a story, and the shift in the field around 2014 falls out naturally. But it buries the thing I actually want to argue, which is that two incompatible measurement approaches have been talking past each other for a decade.

Organising by method puts that front and centre, at a cost:
- Three papers refuse to sit in one camp and would need to appear twice.
- My supervisor's own work reads more naturally in the chronological version.
- The reader loses the sense of the field moving, which matters for the funding case in chapter one.

The real question is whether the review is there to summarise the field or to set up my contribution. If it is the latter, chronology is a comfortable mistake.

When you're ready

Take it for a run.

Start a thinking session and come back with one concrete next move.

History

Thinking sessions

0 total
No thinking sessions yet. This is where the trail will build.